| |
Carr Lot Redevelopment Project:
Multi-Modal Transit Center and Confluence Park
Plans and Public Involvement
Numerous public meetings, reports, articles, forums, notices, and other
measures, such as this Web site, have been used to solicit input and share
information with the public about the future of the Carr Lot. Below are examples of of the notices and documents associated with those events.
Public Meeting was held Wednesday, July 6, 2005, 7:00 p.m., at City Hall to Consider the
Montpelier Multi-Modal Transit & Welcome Center
Environmental Assessment
The City of Montpelier, in association with the Federal Transit Agency as Lead Agency and the Federal Highway Administration as a Cooperating Agency, announces the availability of an Environmental Assessment (EA) of the proposed Montpelier Multi-modal Transit and Welcome Center for public review and comment. An electronic copy of the EA can be downloaded from the links below. Printed copies of the EA can be reviewed at the Kellogg-Hubbard Library at 135 Main Street or the City’s Department of Planning and Community Development Office in City Hall.
The EA assesses the potential impacts of the four main elements of the Montpelier Multi-modal Transit and Welcome Center:
- The purchase of the Carr Lot on Taylor Street for development as the Transit Center;
- The development of the Transit Center itself;
- The extension of the Winooski West shared use path from its current eastern end on Taylor Street across the Transit Center site and across the railroad and new pedestrian/bicycle bridge over the North Branch River to the existing paved areas on the east side of the River; and
- The development of “Confluence Park” on the eastern portion of the site at the confluence of the Winooski and North Branch Rivers.
A public review session will be held at City Hall at 7:00 p.m. on Wednesday, July 6, 2005. Oral or written comments can be submitted at the session. Written comments can also be submitted to the City’s Department of Planning and Community Development Office, City Hall, 39 Main Street, Montpelier, Vermont 05602-2950.
Questions on the EA can be directed to Jim Donovan, ASLA, the EA Project Manager at Wilbur Smith Associates, 4076 Shelburne Road, Shelburne, Vermont 05482, jdonovan@wilbursmith.com, 802-985-2530, or Valerie Capels, Director of Planning and Community Development at City Hall, 802-223-9506.
Links to Downloadable Sections of the Environmental Assessment: (each will open in separate window)
| |
| |
Cover |
1
page, 133 KB  |
| |
Table of
Contents, List of Tables, List of Figures |
6 pages, 37
KB  |
| |
1.0
Project Description and Purpose and Need |
14 pages, 61
KB  |
| |
2.0 Alternatives
to Proposed Action |
4 pages, 32
KB  |
| |
3.0 Environmental
Consequences of the Proposed Action |
56 pages, 179
KB  |
| |
4.0
Section 4(f) and 6(f) Evaluations |
2 pages, 24
KB  |
| |
5.0 Public Involvement and Agency Coordination |
2 pages, 24KB
 |
| |
|
|
| |
Figure
1A. Study Area |
1 page, 290
KB  |
| |
Figure
1B. Monptelier's Designated Downtown |
1 page, 282
KB  |
| |
Figure
1C. Transit Center Site Plan |
1 page, 307
KB  |
| |
Figure
2A. Potential Transit Center Sites |
1 page, 314
KB  |
| |
Figure
3A. Monptelier Parking Areas Map |
1 page, 258
KB  |
| |
Figure
3B. Existing (2005) PM Peak Hour Traffic Volumes |
1 page, 122
KB  |
| |
Figure
3C. Future (2010) No Build PM Peak Hour Traffic Volumes |
1 page, 121
KB  |
| |
Figure
3D. Future (2010) PM Peak Hour Traffic Volumes With Center |
1 page, 121
KB  |
| |
Figure
3E. Floodplains |
1 page, 355
KB  |
| |
Figure
3F. Panoramic Views with and Without Center |
1 page, 385
KB  |
| |
Figure
3Fa. Views of Existing Transit Center Site |
1 page, 292
KB  |
| |
Figure
3G. Area of Potential Effect (APE) |
1 page, 248
KB  |
| |
Figure
3H. Hazardous Materials Risk Sites |
1 page, 318
KB  |
| |
Figure
3I. Hazardous Materials Risk Sites |
1 page, 2, 679
KB  |
| |
Figure
3J. Excerpt from Capital District Master Plan |
1 page, 241
KB  |
| |
Figure
3K. Existing Land Use |
1 page, 340
KB  |
| |
Figure
3L. Bicycle & Pedestrian Circulation in Vicinity of Site |
1 page, 2,212
KB  |
| |
Figure
3M. Fixed Bus Routes |
1 page, 221
KB  |
| |
Figure
3N. Easterm End of Shared Use Path |
1 page, 211
KB  |
| |
|
|
| |
Appendix
A. Carr Lot Survey |
1 page, 272
KB  |
| |
Appendix
B. Purpose & Need Report, March 1, 2002
|
41 pages, 5,541
KB  |
| |
Appendix
C. Correspondence |
1 page, 5 KB
 |
| |
Green
Mountain Transit, April 29, 2005 |
1 page, 5,756
KB  |
| |
Agency
of Natural Resources, Fish & Wildlife, April
11, 2005 |
1 page, 6,410
KB  |
| |
Agency
of Natural Resources, Dept. of Environmental Conservation, April
6, 2005 |
1 page, 6,144
KB  |
| |
FHWA,
E-mail from Christopher Jolly, March 24, 2005 |
1 page, 5,085
KB  |
| |
Corps
of Engineers, March 21, 2005 |
1 page, 5,995
KB  |
| |
FEMA,
March 17, 2005 |
1 page, 5,880
KB  |
| |
Rivis
E-mail, March 16, 2005 |
1 page, 6,507
KB  |
| |
CVRPC,
March 14, 2005 |
1 page, 6,427
KB  |
| |
City
memo, March 10, 2005 |
5 pages, 69,131
KB  |
| |
Appendix
D. Site Plan Alternatives |
1 page, 5 KB
 |
| |
Scheme
A |
1 page, 350
KB  |
| |
Scheme
B |
1 page, 346
KB  |
| |
Scheme
C |
1 page, 391
KB  |
| |
Scheme
D |
1 page, 414
KB  |
| |
Appendix
E. Section 106 Evaluation |
80 pages, 12,617
KB  |
| |
SHPO
letter, May 25, 2005 |
6 pages 21,071
KB  |
| |
Appendix
F. Public Involvement Summaries |
1 page, 6 KB
 |
| |
Excerpt
from Capital District Master Plan, 2000
|
6 pages, 44
KB  |
| |
Winooski
West Path Public Work Session, September 5, 2001
|
2 pages, 5,775
KB  |
| |
Winooski
West Path Public Work Session, February 19, 2002
|
2 pages, 5,419
KB  |
| |
City
Council Minutes Excerpt, March 23, 2005
|
3 pages, 12
KB  |
| |
City
Council Minutes Excerpt, March 30, 2005
|
14 pages, 33
KB  |
| |
City
Council Minutes Excerpt, April 13, 2005
|
2 pages, 10
KB  |
| |
City
Council Minutes Excerpt, April 19, 2005
|
7 pages, 24
KB  |
| |
City
Council Minutes Excerpt, May 4, 2005
|
5 pages, 16
KB  |
| |
Appendix
G. Involved Agencies Circulation Lists |
4 pages, 6 KB
 |
Carr Lot Welcome & Multi-Modal Transit Center
Public Work Session
Wednesday, March 16, 2005
7:00 p.m., City Hall
| Work on the proposed Transit & Welcome Center is progressing. On Wednesday, March 16, 2005, the City will hold a public work session to discuss alternate site plans for the transit center. The results of this exercise will be the basis of City Council discussions in the next few weeks. The City needs to finalize its initial concepts for the site, so that the application and approval process with the Federal Agencies can continue. |
 |
Please join us in helping to convert this site into a vibrant welcome and transit center with green space.
Refreshments will be served.
Contact The Montpelier Planning Dept at
223-9506 or Jim Donovan at jdonovan@wilbursmith.com if you have questions.
More information can also be found at http://www.montpelier-vt.org/wip/carrlot. |
Parking Replacement Study
The Carr Lot Committee calculated that approximately 130 parking spaces would be displaced with the construction of a welcome and multi-modal transit center and park. Wilbur Smith Associates was hired in 2004 to study alternative locations within the downtown to accommodate this displaced parking. Through a process of elimination, analysis, and public input, two sites remained as potential locations for a parking structure that would accommodate the displaced parking. Below are links to their report and its associated attachments.
Final Carr Lot Replacement Parking Report and attachments
| Full Report (very large file) |
19,615 KB, 95 pages  |
| Figure_1. Potential Parking Replacement Areas Near the Carr Lot |
91 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_2. Typical Layout for Efficiency |
162 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_3. Capitol Plaza Parking Lot Existing Conditions |
161 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_4. North Branch Parking Lot Existing Conditions |
89 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_5. Capitol Plaza Potential Parking Structure - First Level |
201 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_6. Capitol Plaza Potential Parking Structure-Second Level |
251 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_7. Capitol Plaza Structure - Taylor Street Simulation |
69 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_8. Capitol Plaza Structure - State Street Photo Simulation |
99 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_9. North Branch Potential Structure - Typical First Level |
97 KB, 1 page  |
| Figure_10. North Branch #1 Potential Structure - Second Level |
135 KB, 1 page
 |
| Figure_11. North Branch #2 Potential Structure - Second Level |
163 KB, 1 page
 |
| Figure_12. North Branch Potential Structure - Photo Simulation |
122 KB, 1 page
 |
| Figure_13. Capital/Carr #1 Parking Structure - Third Level |
103 KB, 1 page
 |
| Figure_14. Capital/Carr #2 Parking Structure - Third Level |
102 KB, 1 page  |
| Appendix_A_parking_studies_summary |
55
KB, 1 page  |
| Appendix_B_Initial_Sites_Under_Consideration |
55 KB, 1 page  |
| Appendix_C_General_Survey |
515 KB, 2 pages
 |
| Appendix_C_General_Survey_Results |
263 KB, 10 pages
 |
| Appendix_C_Carr_Lot_Survey |
382 KB, 2 pages
 |
| Appendix_C_Carr_Lot_Survey_Results |
259 KB, 7 pages
 |
| Appendix_D_First_Public_Work_Session |
1,840 KB, 4 pages  |
| Appendix_D_Public_Work_Session |
1,890 KB, 4 pages
 |
| Appendix_E_Public_Meeting_May_27 |
1,926 KB, 6 pages
 |
| Appendix_F_City_Council_Presentation |
2,185 KB, 6 pages
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_1 |
54 KB, 1 page
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_2 |
91 KB, 1 page
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_3 |
80 KB, 1 page
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_4 |
101 KB, 1 page
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_5 |
63 KB, 1 page
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_6 |
93 KB, 1 page
 |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_7 |
54 KB, 1 page  |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_8 |
61 KB, 1 page  |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_10 |
61 KB, 1 page  |
| Appendix_G_Photo_Simulation_11 |
66 KB, 1 page
 |
| transmittal_letter |
3,694 KB, 1 page  |
Carr Lot/Transit Center
Public Work Session
Tuesday, January 13, 2004, 7:00 - 9:00 p.m., City Hall

Click
on photo for larger overview
|
If a Welcome
and Transit Center is built on what is now a parking lot and the Vermont
Transit bus station site on Taylor Street, up to 130 parking spaces
would need to be replaced somewhere else in the vicinity. Jim Donovan
of Wilbur Smith
Associates will present preliminary findings of where those displaced
parking spaces could be relocated and seek feedback from the public.
A survey is in the process of being distributed to help us better
understand the needs and preferences of downtown parkers. Surveys
can be obtained at City Hall, from various downtown businesses, and
can be downloaded HERE
in MSWord (102 KB) or HERE
in Adobe Acrobat ( 282 KB). Completed surveys should be mailed or
dropped off at City Hall by Tuesday, January 20, 2004. Those downloaded
in Word can be completed and e-mailed back to us at planning@montpelier-vt.org
Parking
Survey in MS Word, (102 KB)
Parking
Survey in PDF ( 282KB) .
The meeting is expected to be broadcast on local Adelphia cable channel
17. For more information contact the Montpelier Planning & Community
Development Department at planning@montpelier-vt.org.
|
Bike Path Conceptual Alignment Analysis
In December 2002, Wilbur Smith Associates completed the conceptual alignment analysis for the continuation of the Winooski West Bike Path, which studies the range of potential routes for continuing the bike path from where it ends at Taylor Street, across the Carr Lot, over the North Branch River, to Main Street, and ultimately connecting to the Winooski East Bike Path on Stone Cutters Way. A key part of this path segment is expected to be included in the multi-modal transit center/confluence park project. A more complete description of the entire bike path project as well a copy of the report can be found at http://www.montpelier-vt.org/wip/bikepaths.
Metcalf & Eddy Targeted Brownfields Assessment Report
In August 2002, the firm of Metcalf & Eddy completed their Target Brownfields Assessment (TBA) report under the Environmental Protection Agency's Response Action Contract (whatever that is). The report and all figures, tables, and appendices is a good 3/4 inches thick. The 23-page report can be downloaded HERE in PDF (1,818 KB).
Open Space Community Forum
The Montpelier Conservation Commission held an Open Space Community Forum on December
14, 2000 to discuss the residents' values and objectives concerning open
space. The preservation of open space was recognized as an important value
and the Carr Lot was identified as an important parcel during this community
discussion.
Capital District Master Plan
The CDMP, adopted by the City Council,
Montpelier Planning Commission, and City-State Commission, in 2000, created
a greenway plan for the Winooski Riverfront Corridor and addressed the feasibility
of a multi-modal transportation center and visitor center.
This Plan was developed with the input and involvement of numerous parties
including representatives from the State of Vermont, the City of Montpelier,
many public and private organizations, and a wide range of citizens.
Carr Lot Design Charrette
The Montpelier Conservation Commission sponsored a day-long Carr Lot Design Charrette
on September 25, 2001. Citizen participants voiced their ideas for the property
including specific suggestions for the design of park open space and the
transportation center. These ideas and suggestions were translated into
detailed drawings by professional architects and incorporated into a report,
which received further public discussion.
Natural Resource Inventory & Open Space Plan
The Montpelier Conservation Commission
and the City Parks department are in the process
of completing a Natural Resource Inventory and Open Space Plan that identifies,
maps, and prioritizes parcels of land in Montpelier for future preservation.
The Carr Lot property is part of this inventory and a related Views and
Vistas report identifies the Carr Lot as having very high visual importance.
Bond Issue Ballot Item
A petition to get this bond issue on
the ballot was signed by over ____ registered voters and passed at the March
2002 Annual meeting by a citywide vote of
1,286 to 1,042. As a result,
the City Council has been authorized to bond for up to $800,000 for the
acquisition and redevelopment of the Carr Lot.
Press Coverage
There have been several articles in the local
Times-Argus and Montpelier Bridge newspapers that have informed the
public about the Carr Lot project.
- Roadblock stalls planned Capital garage, Times-Argus, by Sky Barsch, April 29, 2005
- Lot off Main Street picked for capital city garage, Times-Argus, by Sky Barsch, April 20, 2005
- Transit center location chosen, Times-Argus, by Sky Barsch, April 1, 2005
- Input invited for transit center workshop, Times-Argus, by Sky Barsch, March 16, 2005
- Montpelier's farmers' market seeks new digs, Times-Argus, by Sky Barsch, August 13, 2004
- Tight parking riles Montpelier businesses, Times-Argus, by Patrick Joy, July 10, 2004
- Transportation focus of Montpelier meetings, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, June 23, 2004
- Car lot plan sees 2007 finish, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, May 16, 2003
- Bike path goes for Act 250 permit, Times-Argus, by Sky Barsch, May 11, 2004
- Parking kicks off master plan hearings, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, May 9, 2003
- Montpelier bike path progresses, Times-Argus, by Patrick Joy, March 24, 2004
- Carr Lot look to Jeffords for funding, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, February 13, 2003
- Vermont Mutal building deal falls through, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, January 22, 2003
- Students redesign Montpelier, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, May 28, 2002
- City may get 'green space,' transit stop, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, April 12, 2002
- Montpelier school budget defeated, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mill, March 6, 2002
- Montpelier budgets, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mill, March 6, 2002
- Grant may be boon to transit center, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, November 16, 2001
- Community discusses plans for Carr Lot, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, September 26, 2001
- Riverfront project continues, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, May 30, 2001
- Montpelier addressing downtown parking, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, May 10, 2001
- City officials support statehouse garage, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, April 20, 2001
- Riverfront park site wins environmental study grant, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, April 1, 2001
- Does parking garage have the support?, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, March 1, 2001
- Montpelier residents divided over garage, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, February 22, 2001
- Traffic, parking issues main concern of city council meeting, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, February 15, 2001
- Group tackles questions about proposed garage, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, February 2, 2001
- Montpelier plans riverfront park and parking garage, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, November 29, 2000
- City's seed money boosts riverfront plans, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, September 17, 2000
- City-State projects supported, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, July 28, 2000
- Councilors renew debate over Montpelier's riverfront, Times-Argus, by Stephen Mills, April 27, 2000
- Plan sees beauty spot along rivers - someday, Times-Argus, by David W. Smith, April 23, 2000
Letters to the Editor
Numerous letters to the Editor have also been published in the local
Times-Argus, some of which are listed below.
- Carr lot hearing coming Thursday, Times-Argus, May 25, 2004 (first letter on page)
- Thoughts sought on Carr Lot, Times-Argus, March 26, 2003 (first letter on page)
- Future Carr Lot Committee, Times-Argus, March 30, 2002 (7th letter on page)
- Seeking help, Times-Argus, February 8, 2002 (2nd letter on page)
- Commission needs your assistance, Times-Argus, June 5, 2000 (1st letter on page)
For More Information, contact
City of Montpelier
39 Main Street, City Hall
Montpelier, VT 05062-2950
Beverlee Hill, Assistant City Manager
(802) 223-9512
bhill@montpelier-vt.org |
|
City of Montpelier
Planning and Community
Development Department
39 Main Street, City Hall
Montpelier, VT 05062-2950
(802) 223-9506
planning@montpelier-vt.org
|
Carr Lot Advisory Committee
39 Main Street, City Hall
Montpelier,
VT 05062-2950
Jon Anderson, Chair
janderson@vtlaw1.com |
|
Conservation Commission
39 Main Street, City Hall
Montpelier, VT 05062-2950
Kris Hammer, Co-Chair
|
Updated November 9, 2005
|